Stella Watson, the star editor of Burke Fashion Magazine, takes an island trip to clear her mind and focus on her infamous Shamed List column. When she falls for a man who is on the List, she is faced with a tough decision between her heart and her career.

When her relationship falls apart days before bringing her fianc?home, Hope (Brittany Lucio) scrambles to find the perfect Christian man her family expects. Jesse (Chico Benymon) happily volunteers but soon realizes he is in over his head.